PH Tragedy of Errors in Pandemic Response; DILG Files Charges on 397 Bgy.Officials on SAP Anomalies

“Marami pang kasunod ito.  Ang datos na ito ay mula April 1 hanggang June 16 pa lamang kaya doon sa mga gumawa ng kalokohan noong unang pamimigay ng SAP, sinasabi ko sa inyo na hindi kayo makakalusot,” he said.

(Many will follow. The data is only from April 1 to June 16 so barangay officials who did something wrong during the first tranche of SAP will not get away.)

Articles Inside:

DILG: 397 local officials face raps for anomalous cash aid distribution -

The Philippines’ Pandemic Response: A Tragedy of Errors -

The effect of ECQ/GCQ on people’s lives -

DILG: 397 local gov’t officials facing raps over irregularities in cash aid distribution

Photo Source:

Nearly 400 barangay and local government officials are facing criminal charges for alleged anomalies in the distribution of cash aid for families affected by the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19).

The Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG) on Tuesday said it has filed criminal raps against 397 local executives from the total of 663 officials that have been subjected to investigation.

“A total of 663 individuals have been subjected to investigation by the PNP-CIDG, 267 of these are elected barangay officials and some are local government officials,” Interior Secretary Eduardo Año said in a statement.

“The rest, 396, are other government employees or civilian accomplices of those elected local officials,” he added.

More cases are expected to be filed against barangay officials in the next few days, Año said, as the Philippine National Police (PNP) conducts case build-up and investigation on 67 cases.

Five more cases will be filed within the week, he added.

“Marami pang kasunod ito.  Ang datos na ito ay mula April 1 hanggang June 16 pa lamang kaya doon sa mga gumawa ng kalokohan noong unang pamimigay ng SAP, sinasabi ko sa inyo na hindi kayo makakalusot,” he said.

(Many will follow. The data is only from April 1 to June 16 so barangay officials who did something wrong during the first tranche of SAP will not get away.)


The Philippines’ Pandemic Response: A Tragedy of Errors


The Philippine government has been boasting that as early as March 16, they had the gumption to implement a lockdown in major cities and provinces in response to the unfolding COVID-19 pandemic. However, Manila’s overall response to the pandemic has been fraught with incompetence and rife with terror. 

The implementation of the Enhanced Community Quarantine (ECQ) came on the heels of serious negligence — namely, the authorities failing to keep up with the preventive measures of neighboring countries and grossly underestimating the virus. What’s worse, instead of easing the overall burden that the virus unleashed on the country, it seems the last resort lockdown itself added to a plethora of problems without adequately addressing the primary crisis at hand: ensuring public health and safety.

Strict compliance with the ECQ is ordered for all citizens, with the exception of frontline professionals, until at least May 15. That has meant curfews, harsh penalties for being outside, and an impoverished population descending into hunger. 

The global crisis is first and foremost a public health issue, but Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte has faced the coronavirus pandemic in a decidedly militaristic fashion. Since the lockdown went into effect, he has peddled the narrative of pasaways or “undisciplined” citizens as responsible for the ensuing problems. He has also brought up unsubstantiated activities of guerrilla groups as threats to government aid efforts without conceding any missteps in his management. On top of deploying thousands of police and soldiers throughout the archipelago to enforce the ECQ, Duterte has on two occasions threatened the public with all-out martial law. There have been moments of abject incompetence from those in power around the world, but using the pandemic as a reason for increasingly flexing authoritarian muscles spells danger for the Philippines post-lockdown.

China and Allies First

While Singapore, Taiwan, Vietnam, and Hong Kong took the early initiative on travel restrictions and emergency measures, the Philippines was noticeably late to follow suit. Duterte ordered a travel ban only for passengers coming from Wuhan, China specifically on January 31, a day after the first case of COVID-19 was confirmed in the Philippines. A few days later, the ban was expanded to the entirety of China, with the delay, as affirmed by Department of Health (DOH) chief Francisco Duque, attributed to a reluctance to upset relations with China.

Downplaying the hysteria as Filipinos scrambled for protective, medical, and sanitation equipment, Duterte attempted to allay fears in early February, saying there was “nothing really to be scared of.” 

Meanwhile, there was a noticeable rapid decline in supplies of items like face masks. On the day the first case was confirmed in the Philippines, presidential spokesperson Salvador Panelo clarified that the government wouldn’t be distributing masks to vulnerable populations as it had none to give out. But a few days earlier, government leaders were touting Philippine generosity in aiding China with a donation of masks worth $1.4 million that were shipped to Wuhan. 

A full month passed before Duterte officially declared the country in a “State of Public Health Emergency” on March 9, five days before the number of confirmed COVID 19 patients breached the 100 mark. A week later, the government announced its initial emergency response package to the virus, totaling $535 million. With hospitals reportedly lacking in personal protective equipment (PPE), the financial stimulus came with disheartening details that half of the amount was intended for boosting the tourism industry and only 11.4 percent was aimed toward the acquisition of testing kits and other materials to curb the virus. 

The World Health Organization (WHO) has urged the mass production and use of testing kits as a basic necessity in combating the pandemic, yet even the DOH on March 20 felt that there was “no need for mass testing yet,” a reminder of how they sorely misread the situation. 

Doctor Josh San Pedro, a co-convener of the Coalition of People’s Right to Health (CPRH), explained to The Diplomat that “health authorities may have been complacent, as it was only in mid-March that significant improvements were made to testing capacity, despite locally-made kits being ready as early as February. With a slashed budget for disease surveillance and epidemiology for 2020, contact tracing was increasingly difficult in Metro Manila for example, one of the world’s most densely populated cities.”

More infuriating for the public was the fact that the department confessed, two days later, to giving preferential treatment and testing to 34 unnamed public officials and their families. The president of PDP-Laban (Partido Demokratiko Pilipino–Lakas ng Bayan), Duterte’s party, Senator Aquilino “Koko” Pimentel III, was among the legislators who tested positive for COVID-19. He subsequently drew flak for violating quarantine protocols to visit his pregnant wife in the hospital, putting all the medical staff at risk. The incident has warranted no probe nor sanction from the authorities.

It wasn’t until April 14 that the DOH commenced mass testing to rectify their earlier errors, but some critics say present efforts are still gravely insufficient. San Pedro adds, “Despite being endowed with tens of thousands of test kits in donations we failed to meet the target of 8,000 tests per day at the end of April. Guidelines for ‘expansion’ of testing were only released on April 16. Majority of testing centers are still in Metro Manila, while only six are located in the provinces. Much is still needed in expanding testing throughout the archipelago, such as increasing testing and quarantine centers to minimize backlogs.”

Even with the DOH announcing that the country is starting to “flatten the curve,” coupled with a new target of 30,000 tests per day by the end of May, there is still some doubt as to whether this is achievable. As of writing, only 0.1 percent of the population has been tested. After analyzing government data, mathematics professor Lex Muga hopes that the target can be achieved but explained that “community transmission has not stopped. When we can see that the number of cases are decreasing daily is when we can assume the curve is flattening. But there are conditions, such as mass testing. DOH data is based on those who are confirmed positive with the virus but it has thousands of backlogs which we don’t yet know the results.”

Since the start of the pandemic, China has maintained a favorable position in the Duterte administration’s eyes. Even with ECQ measures still in place in early May, the government allowed for large-scale gambling with the re-opening of Philippine Offshore Gaming Operations or POGOs, which have a significant Chinese workforce and capital.

Public officials are currently mulling the extension of the lockdown until June 15, which indicates that the country isn’t on the verge of managing the pandemic, contrary to DOH pronouncements. 

However, Dr. Julie Caguiat, also of CPRH, mentioned that there should be a better roadmap to attaining this with “mass testing not only for those with symptoms. But we should be testing for all, not only by priority. Hopefully, there can be random testing in areas that may have bigger concentrations of people.” Caguiat also noted that testing operations should be free (some cost around $60), with clear procedures on contact tracing for all — something that has yet to be undertaken, unlike in neighboring countries. 

What’s Scarier Than the Virus?

In the immediate aftermath of the lockdown, poor Filipinos especially were distraught by the prospect of contending with hunger. With no available sources of income and virtually nonexistent savings, many homeless and slum dwellers bore the brunt of the ECQ. 

On April 1, more than a hundred people from the city slums of Sitio San Roque gathered on a nearby highway to voice their discontent and demand food and aid. Their already poverty-stricken community, like many others, had found it near impossible to deal with having no livelihood or even space to stock up on food in such tight quarters. Twenty-one of the hungry protesters were beaten and arrested by the police. The incident summarily reflected the handling of grievances by the authorities during the lockdown.

The arrests occurred just over a week after Duterte granted himself emergency powers to deal with the pandemic. With newly acquired powers he called for an even stricter implementation of the ECQ. He had a message for anyone who intended to replicate the behavior of the San Roque residents: “I will not hesitate. My orders are to the police and military, as well as village officials, if there is any trouble, or occasions where there’s violence and your lives are in danger: shoot them dead.”

Taking his cue, the police declared they will stop issuing warnings and will simply arrest even low-level violators of the quarantine rules. At a police press briefing in early April, arrests were shown to have spiked during the quarantine, with the cops nabbing an average of more than a thousand people per day nationwide. 

Since then there have been reports and sightings of extreme prejudice in the operations of law enforcement. Stories such as those of a mentally ill Army veteran who was shot dead for being outside and a fish vendor severely beaten for not wearing a face mask have become commonplace. Arrests have also extended to anyone caught criticizing the administration’s perceived failures during the pandemic. Police have begun to target relief workers and even people posting unflattering opinions about Duterte online. The biggest single haul of the crackdown came on Labor Day, May 1. Ninety-two individuals across five cities were imprisoned while either engaging in feeding programs or joining online protests. 

Prominent human rights group KARAPATAN slammed the mass arrests, saying the regime should refocus its efforts. The group’s secretary general Cristina Palabay said, “The Duterte government and its minions [are] exploiting quarantine measures to harass, vilify, and rabidly arrest — even kill — activists. Instead of responding to the socioeconomic needs of the people, these mass arrests will only worsen the plight of the poor. Those who are helping the poor are being put in jail.” 

Palabay pointed to the murder of relief worker Jory Porquia the day before Labor Day by suspected elements of law enforcement as the backdrop of her comments.

In the last week of March, Duterte announced a larger economic relief package of nearly $4 billion, primarily for low-income families, dubbed the Social Amelioration Program (SAP). Plagued by chronic procedural problems in the Department of Social Welfare and Development (DSWD), there are constant complaints of the SAP not reaching its intended beneficiaries and the allocations per town being far too small to do much good.

Former DSWD chief and now of the broad network CURE COVID (Citizen’s Urgent Response to End COVID-19) Judy Taguiwalo criticized the use of an outdated census to guide the state’s relief effort. She told The Diplomat, “Limiting the financial assistance to a list based on the 2015 census created major delays in the distribution. They should instead opt for a universal approach, extending financial assistance to everyone in need throughout the process. People are lining up under the heat of the summer sun desperate for assistance. Maybe social workers can go house to house, but they are also lacking PPEs and working long hours. Going to every door also requires a universal approach. The state should welcome the involvement of civil society groups and the private sector in the relief effort and reduce obstacles of various permits for their participation.”

Robert Lunzaga, a community leader in the province of Bulacan from the national urban poor group Kadamay, told The Diplomat that not only were SAP allotments too few for their predominantly impoverished town but those aligned with organizations critical of the administration were bullied by the authorities. He was brought to the local military encampment and told to cease all political activity, surrender to the government, and only then would they receive any aid. Other locals have recounted similar stories. Lunzaga adds, “We have four barangays (towns) in the Pandi municipality, each with more than a thousand poor families. But each barangay has only been allotted around 400 slots for the SAP. Many people are desperate and fighting over aid … just to get $100 to $150.”

To deal with the inadequacies, Congress’ Makabayan (Patriotic) bloc, composed of several opposition parties, has forwarded a bill to expand the SAP in the hopes of reaching out to more Filipinos in need. They particularly noted that 1.7 million workers have been excluded from aid programs. 

“It is reprehensible that while Duterte’s economic managers discuss the need for economic recovery from the COVID-19 fallout. Filipino workers who make the daily operation of transport systems, factories, and malls possible are still largely left out in the government’s aid efforts,” said the coalition in a joint statement. 

The whole world is looking forward to a return to some semblance of normalcy. But what makes the Philippine government one of the worst examples of handling the pandemic is its incompetence married with militarism threaded throughout its responses. The backlash facing Filipinos now and after the quarantine is quite a distressing picture. It is a bleak one marred by a totalitarian streak and the people’s increased realization that the state is more intent on filling jails and the pockets of Chinese businesses than starving stomachs. 


The effect of ECQ/GCQ on people’s lives

Article Source:

Photo Source:

Our village tennis coach is at the end of his rope. Unable to work for 93 days, he made ends meet by working as a part time gardener and relying on subsidies from the government. His wife, an inventory clerk, was laid-off in the second week of the ECQ. With gardening gigs dried up and subsidies from government now depleted, our coach has resorted to asking (begging) the villagers for financial aid. The father of two is facing eviction from his apartment and is finding it hard to provide three meals a day for his family. Nowadays, a meal consists of a pack of instant noodles and an egg. His situation is tragic considering he has a degree in physical kinetics.

I was one of those he texted for financial assistance. I helped in whatever capacity I could. This man is no longer the healthy, cheerful athlete he was three months ago. He is broken – beaten by despair and crushed by his circumstances. He must have lost 25 pounds as the tendons in his neck are now protruding.

His eyes turned glassy when he received my ayuda. I could tell it was from feelings of gratitude, shame and fear. With desperation, he told me that his family would not survive if the quarantine continues. If malnourishment wont kill them, then depression will. He mentioned suicide in the course of our conversation. The man’s back is against the wall and for as long as the quarantine lasts, there is no way out for him.

Meanwhile, inside the confines of our village, a neighbor (and friend) has a different problem. He invested in boutique hotels to cash-in on our booming tourism industry.

Over the last seven years, he built three hotels in Manila and Calabarzon with two new projects underway in Cebu and Boracay. His expansion was financed by internal capital and bank loans

My neighbor planned to grow his chain to ten hotels, operate them to maximum profitability and sell them to a bigger chain for 12 times its annual profits. The proceeds would be enough to pay off his debts whilst providing him with a handsome sum for his golden years.

The new Cebu and Boracay hotels were due to open last March. But due to the pandemic, the opening is postponed indefinitely.

My friend faces serious financial problems. The three existing hotels have an occupancy rate below 10 percent and its revenues are not enough to cover payroll, let alone other expenses. As for the two new hotels, he can no longer count on a healthy influx of guests considering the absence of foreign tourists and the continued restrictions on domestic travel. He must now support the overhead expenses of five hotels without the revenues to back it up.

Making matters worse is that bank amortization for his loans are now due. Even with extreme cost-cutting and loan restructuring, my desperate neighbor will bleed cash. If nothing changes, he faces insolvency in three months.

Government has not helped. While it boasts of a multi-billion rescue package for businesses in distress, it has chosen to rely on the banking system to dispense these loans. Problem is, banks shy away from SMEs and industries deemed high-risk, like the tourism sector. They grant the lion’s share of available funds to the conglomerates, particularly those who owe them hundreds of millions. It serves the bank’s best interest to keep these conglomerates alive.

My tennis coach and neighbor belong to different worlds, but they share the same despair. Millions of Filipinos are going through the same experience.

All these put to question whether government’s harsh prescription to curb the pandemic is worth it.

With its extreme quarantine measures, the IATF needlessly destroyed whole industries. It caused more job layoffs than necessary and caused enough bankruptcies among MSMEs to destroy the very backbone of the economy. And the worse is not over – the economy will contract by four percent this year and this will trigger even more layoffs and financial catastrophes among private firms.

The tragedy of it all is that despite its draconian prescription, the IATF still can’t claim victory over the Wuhan virus. Infections are still up and now migrating to cities like Cebu. It can’t even determine where we are in the infection curve since its base data is inaccurate. Even at this late stage, the IATF has yet to achieve 30,000 COVID tests per day.

The IATF mistakenly thought that militaristic quarantines would be enough to arrest the virus. As such, it did not embark on a program of intense testing and tracing until mid-April. Worse, it failed to consider that we have a young population with a median age of 23.5, who are able to resist the virus.

The IATF solution, the ECQ and GCQ, were overkill. It gave little consideration to its effect on the economy and its effect on people’s lives. It has caused more anguish and despair than called for.

I said it before and I’ll say it again – if the IATF had included economists and real scientists into its fold (not only military men and a doctor/politician), it would have adopted a more balanced strategy. Perhaps a strategy where testing and tracing were the priority and the lockdown only applied to the barangays where those infected reside. Not the whole Luzon and key cities.

The IATF failed to calibrate the consequences of its strategy versus its benefits. It bulldozed its way with its militaristic quarantine which is not only failing, but also causing hunger, desperation, malnutrition (and deaths) of our countrymen, not to mention driving 200,000 MSMEs to bankruptcy. Meanwhile, New Zealand, Australia and Vietnam have flattened their curve and saved their economies with much milder measures.

While it may be true that the economy may recover in a year or two on the back of infrastructure spending, it will not restore the livelihood of all 4.9 million Filipinos who have lost their jobs. That will take at least a decade. It will not restore the businesses and life’s work of our hardworking entrepreneurs.

There is nothing we can do about the damage wrought by the IATF’s quarantine. The best it can do, as we move forward, is to open up the economy with the necessary safety protocols. Stop using fear to control our people into submission because fear is the foil to our consumer-driven economy.

Lets be honest – the fumbles of the IATF put to question the competence of this administration.


©2019 by bloggersjournalph. Proudly created with